sockwithaticket wrote: Mon Oct 24, 2022 1:59 pm
tc27 wrote: Mon Oct 24, 2022 1:34 pm
Sunaks got (in theory) the support of a majority of MPs that's the only legitimate requirement to PM.
People talking about him being illegitimate because he has won a general election don't understand how a Parliamentary system works and are perhaps unknowingly repeating the populist talking point Boris Johnson was pushing (that the GE was a personnel mandate for him).
In fairness the same points were made of Truss and Johnson (on his initial takeover) and I recall some Tory grumbling about Brown taking over Labour without a general election. While it might run contrary to how a parliamentary system works, it is a narrative the Tories have had a hand in crafting, so it can't be a surprise when it's turned on them.
Equally, while our electoral system as written may not be about the Prime Minister, it de facto is (at least in part). Who ends up in Number 10 is very much an influence on many who cast their vote.
It's all very well saying that it's the system you have, & how many times it's happened before; but I'd be sure most of these transitions had people making exactly the same complaints at the time. You just don't change the Leader of the Country like you do your socks, so if there's a reason why you have to, it's almost certainly an inflection point for the entire Country, & not just the Party.
The other thing that makes these transitions controversial, is if the new PM decides to tear up the Manifesto, that brought the party to power, & pretend that having no mandate isn't a problem; that was Truss's mistake. Now the Tories are going to double down, & implement austerity, without ever levelling with the Country, or offering the voters a chance to choose between Manifestos on how to get out of the hole 12 years of Tory Governments have stuck the Country in ?