Tichtheid wrote: Mon Nov 20, 2023 10:05 am
shaggy wrote: Mon Nov 20, 2023 8:46 am
Tichtheid wrote: Mon Nov 20, 2023 12:33 am
What I was referring to in that point was the Left v Right viewpoint, nothing to do with Israel. I believe that health, education, utilities, travel infrastructure, defence and other security (police, borders etc) should be funded for the benefit of everyone, there is no real profit to be made in those areas and should not be subject to rapacious market forces where the aim is to reward shareholders, rather than the quality of service being the end goal in of itself.
OTOH, make all the widgets you can and sell them in the private sector, fill your boots, I'm all for it, just pay your taxes.
The ones who seek to make a profit out of the health service or education etc, that is the "they" or "them" I was referring to. I know there are some that will never accept that point of view, hence my admittedly adversarial language. I'd rather win them over, I really would.
So you want to defeat the many private education facilities that are the ones that can actually cater for young people with very complex needs? How do you propose those who need a residential placement to enable any form of life to actually survive?
The private sector exists in the special needs space because decades and generations of governments have dismantled the public sector. This didn’t start happening in 2011.
I'll bring this here from the Gazza thread because this is a slightly more appropriate thread for this topic.
Ideally I'd like every child's needs to be met in a way that the there isn't a profit motive behind the provision, I'm on a quick fly-by right now, but I thought this article was worth a read
https://weownit.org.uk/blog/how-cuts-an ... -education
Agree with Tichtheid that those services such as healthcare, education, water & sewage, defence, transport, etc should all be owned and run by the state for the good of the population as a whole.
Water and sewage is an interesting one - I think England is the only country in the world that has privatized its entire water and sewage system. Other areas who have done similar such as some states in US have a pretty poor track record - just look at the Flint debacle in Michigan. Water and sewage is recognised the world over as a public health issue and this was built on the work by Snow and others in eradicating cholera outbreaks in London. Only England privatized its entire system and we all know how badly that has gone. It now appears that c70% of the water companies are owned by non UK companies including from Hong Kong, China, US, Germany, Australia, etc. It has essentially become a cash cow for investment companies and hedge funds who can extract huge dividends and carry little or no risk to them and if they get fined for shit in rivers they can just put prices up. Water quality in rivers and coasts, water distribution and sewage treatment are all major problems , particularly now that we have left the EU and are beginning to diverge from the EU standards. Water companies are now trailing the need to increase water prices as the Gov push them to increase investment - they take the dividends and customers pay higher prices.
You could say the same for many other 'privatized industries' which are also in effect cash cows for private sector who are guaranteed income streams via subsidies from Gov whilst service quality falls. The only winners with the privatization of key services are big businesses and no doubt the Tory MPs and their mates who will secure well paid seats on boards after they step down. Calll me cynical but then show me I am wrong!