Re: B&I Lions 2025 Official Thread
Posted: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm
There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
A place where escape goats go to play
https://www.notplanetrugby.com/
It makes sense when you consider the 10 and 12 as a pair, which is or was the kiwi system.erictheodorecartman wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 12:35 pm I found this on a reddit post:
The 1903 All Black captain, Jimmy Duncan, is credited with coining the name five-eighths when he decided to take a player from the forwards to add to the backs. The backs at that time consisted of two half-backs, three three-quarters, and a full-back. As the additional player stood between half-back and three-quarters, Duncan came up with the term five-eighths according to the fraction between them.
The player at five-eighths, also known as the five-eighth, could take the ball back to the forwards or pass it on to the three-quarters.
As the game of rugby union evolved, the two half-back positions acquired separate functions. The outside half-back, now known as the outhalf or fly-half, became the first five-eighths in New Zealand under the two five-eighths system. The next player on his outside was called the second five-eighths
I know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
I think he is the epitome of the modern full back. Fast and physical, and importantly can step in to play ten on the other side of the break down from your fly half to disguise your line of attack.Wylie Coyote wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 3:17 pmI know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
I agree, he is a bit wasted on the wing. In saying that, he has been playing so well over the last 18 months or so that you might just want him on the pitch anywhereWylie Coyote wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 3:17 pmI know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
My son told me he got a 3 month subscriptionSlick wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:36 pm Has anyone else got the Sky sports subscription through NOW?
Just signed up to the £26 a month for 6 months then it’s £36 - I think I can cancel after the Lions tour but not sure…
There is an oddity in many teams that they simply don't bring the wingers off the wing enough, but it is an option. And you get 2 15s in defence.Wylie Coyote wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 3:17 pmI know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
Slick wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:36 pm Has anyone else got the Sky sports subscription through NOW?
Just signed up to the £26 a month for 6 months then it’s £36 - I think I can cancel after the Lions tour but not sure…
I believe it is a 6 month minimum term.Slick wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:36 pm Has anyone else got the Sky sports subscription through NOW?
Just signed up to the £26 a month for 6 months then it’s £36 - I think I can cancel after the Lions tour but not sure…
FFS, the wording is very ambiguous but the normal full price monthly deal didn’t come up as an option.Tichtheid wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:52 pmSlick wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:36 pm Has anyone else got the Sky sports subscription through NOW?
Just signed up to the £26 a month for 6 months then it’s £36 - I think I can cancel after the Lions tour but not sure…
I'm pretty sure that deal is for a six month minimum term, but you might get the Rugby Championship too, I haven't been able to find out who the broadcaster is this year.
I went for the one month at full price, that allows me to cancel when I want.
They usually offer a deal when you go to cancel.
If you cancel at the end they'll likely offer you another cheap deal. They usually do for me.Slick wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 8:50 pmFFS, the wording is very ambiguous but the normal full price monthly deal didn’t come up as an option.Tichtheid wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:52 pmSlick wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:36 pm Has anyone else got the Sky sports subscription through NOW?
Just signed up to the £26 a month for 6 months then it’s £36 - I think I can cancel after the Lions tour but not sure…
I'm pretty sure that deal is for a six month minimum term, but you might get the Rugby Championship too, I haven't been able to find out who the broadcaster is this year.
I went for the one month at full price, that allows me to cancel when I want.
They usually offer a deal when you go to cancel.
It did say that is you cancel before the end of the deal you can’t get the same deal again which made me think it’s cancel at any time. We shall see!
From a simplistic pov the Scottish bavkline has consistently cut the Aussies apart for the last seven or eight years. More so than the other Lions nations. So you take that back line and look at where you can improve on it, if you're a decent coach. I have a feeling Farrell might have his guys though, and then see where he can fit this Scots round that.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:43 pmThere is an oddity in many teams that they simply don't bring the wingers off the wing enough, but it is an option. And you get 2 15s in defence.Wylie Coyote wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 3:17 pmI know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
Depends a bit just how much you're expecting your 15 to be covering (against) kicks, because pretty much no one is better at that than Keenan, Keenan reads the game brilliantly and works his nuts off covering the backfield. But I can't say I've any idea how the Aussies will play, indeed when I saw their recent squad I figured I could pick 10-12 of them out of a lineup, maybe
In a side that's allowed to play and often loses anyway so the pressure is less. Not that I'm especially fussed it the backline is Irish and/or ScottishBiffer wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:00 pmFrom a simplistic pov the Scottish bavkline has consistently cut the Aussies apart for the last seven or eight years. More so than the other Lions nations. So you take that back line and look at where you can improve on it, if you're a decent coach. I have a feeling Farrell might have his guys though, and then see where he can fit this Scots round that.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:43 pmThere is an oddity in many teams that they simply don't bring the wingers off the wing enough, but it is an option. And you get 2 15s in defence.Wylie Coyote wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 3:17 pm
I know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.
Depends a bit just how much you're expecting your 15 to be covering (against) kicks, because pretty much no one is better at that than Keenan, Keenan reads the game brilliantly and works his nuts off covering the backfield. But I can't say I've any idea how the Aussies will play, indeed when I saw their recent squad I figured I could pick 10-12 of them out of a lineup, maybe
More than Ireland and Wales, perhaps. England's record against them, even as we declined against other nations is very good. In part because Aus have been crap for most of the last 8 years.Biffer wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:00 pmFrom a simplistic pov the Scottish bavkline has consistently cut the Aussies apart for the last seven or eight years. More so than the other Lions nations. So you take that back line and look at where you can improve on it, if you're a decent coach. I have a feeling Farrell might have his guys though, and then see where he can fit this Scots round that.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:43 pm
There is an oddity in many teams that they simply don't bring the wingers off the wing enough, but it is an option. And you get 2 15s in defence.
Depends a bit just how much you're expecting your 15 to be covering (against) kicks, because pretty much no one is better at that than Keenan, Keenan reads the game brilliantly and works his nuts off covering the backfield. But I can't say I've any idea how the Aussies will play, indeed when I saw their recent squad I figured I could pick 10-12 of them out of a lineup, maybe
The 6 month option I was getting was slightly different and never mentioned a 6 month minimum term, just that it was available at the reduced price for 6 months. The flexible £36 option wasn’t available. We shall see!topofthemoon wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:05 pm They do seem to being a bit sneaky. If you have used Now TV before and are logged in when you go to offers it will only show you the 6 month minimum term for £26 per month option.
This link has all 3 possible options including the day pass (£14.99 for 24 hours) and the flexible month (£34.99 per month):
https://www.nowtv.com/plans/new/sports
A good guide would be how Farrell has picked wingers to date. He's more or less ignored Stockdale when fit and generally selected wingers with good workrate and ability to bring others into the game. Kinghorn would have a good chance of featuring there even if Keenan gets the 15 slot.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:43 pmThere is an oddity in many teams that they simply don't bring the wingers off the wing enough, but it is an option. And you get 2 15s in defence.Wylie Coyote wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 3:17 pmI know Toulouse play Kinghorn there but they have like 4 international fullbacks in the squad so they have to fit everyone in. I just don't see him as wing. He is such a creative player for those around him, his offloading and all round ball handling is wasted on the wing, let him pop up across the back field and he will excel, he gets the best out of his wingers and has such a high ceiling athletically and skills wise.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 2:18 pm There remains the valid option to pick Keenan at 15 and Kinghorn on the wing.
Depends a bit just how much you're expecting your 15 to be covering (against) kicks, because pretty much no one is better at that than Keenan, Keenan reads the game brilliantly and works his nuts off covering the backfield. But I can't say I've any idea how the Aussies will play, indeed when I saw their recent squad I figured I could pick 10-12 of them out of a lineup, maybe
I'm not sure that there is any less pressure on Scotland than there is on any other nation. I think Biffer has a point, put that backline behind a pack which pressurises opponents into making mistakes and leaving gaps due to being on the back foot and you'd really see them let rip.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 10:04 pmIn a side that's allowed to play and often loses anyway so the pressure is less. Not that I'm especially fussed it the backline is Irish and/or ScottishBiffer wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:00 pmFrom a simplistic pov the Scottish bavkline has consistently cut the Aussies apart for the last seven or eight years. More so than the other Lions nations. So you take that back line and look at where you can improve on it, if you're a decent coach. I have a feeling Farrell might have his guys though, and then see where he can fit this Scots round that.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 7:43 pm
There is an oddity in many teams that they simply don't bring the wingers off the wing enough, but it is an option. And you get 2 15s in defence.
Depends a bit just how much you're expecting your 15 to be covering (against) kicks, because pretty much no one is better at that than Keenan, Keenan reads the game brilliantly and works his nuts off covering the backfield. But I can't say I've any idea how the Aussies will play, indeed when I saw their recent squad I figured I could pick 10-12 of them out of a lineup, maybe
I think that’s referring to the S4C diverge you can access through I playerSaintK wrote: Fri Jun 20, 2025 11:22 am Noticed on Where's the Match that the Lions v Argies is on iPlayer tonight.
Having searched iPLayer I can't find it anywhere.!!!!!
Aaah!
S4C sometimes do English commentary on the red button I think.SaintK wrote: Fri Jun 20, 2025 12:20 pmAaah!
Can't see it there either though to be honest I don't fancy watching it witha Welsh commentary![]()
No, just no. Mr Benn did not appear by magic, that was the shopkeeper!Tichtheid wrote: Fri Jun 20, 2025 7:44 amI'm not sure that there is any less pressure on Scotland than there is on any other nation. I think Biffer has a point, put that backline behind a pack which pressurises opponents into making mistakes and leaving gaps due to being on the back foot and you'd really see them let rip.Rhubarb & Custard wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 10:04 pmIn a side that's allowed to play and often loses anyway so the pressure is less. Not that I'm especially fussed it the backline is Irish and/or ScottishBiffer wrote: Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:00 pm
From a simplistic pov the Scottish bavkline has consistently cut the Aussies apart for the last seven or eight years. More so than the other Lions nations. So you take that back line and look at where you can improve on it, if you're a decent coach. I have a feeling Farrell might have his guys though, and then see where he can fit this Scots round that.
Unless Fagerson does a Mr Benn and appears back on tour as if by magic, then I can't see Scotland being represented in the test side pack, maybe Schoeman on the pine
Thanks I'll take a look later this eveningOxbow wrote: Fri Jun 20, 2025 12:31 pmS4C sometimes do English commentary on the red button I think.
Yes, they do for the URC matches, although confusingly if you select the English commentary, you get the Welsh one, & if you select the Welsh one, you get the English one on my TVOxbow wrote: Fri Jun 20, 2025 12:31 pmS4C sometimes do English commentary on the red button I think.
Not
Hasty edit there...