Paddington Bear wrote: Wed Feb 08, 2023 10:35 pm
Biffer wrote: Wed Feb 08, 2023 9:48 pm
GogLais wrote: Wed Feb 08, 2023 8:14 pm
The other thing is that in the last couple of hundred years or so pretty well every major country has had to rebuild itself after either war or revolution. Or it came into being in that period. Sometimes it’s been for the better, sometimes for the worse. I wouldn’t want to live through it but we should have had another revolution sometime after 1688.
You might have missed WWII? Half the country needed rebuilt after that.
And wrt revolution how about 1745? And 1916?
That the Jacobites failed miserably and ended up strengthening the power of the British state and the 1688 settlement would be a pretty radical point of difference when compared to the revolutions Gog is referencing.
Likewise WW2, you have to differentiate *why* things had to be rebuilt. Unlike the other European combatants, the established order in Britain managed to emerge as a victor and unoccupied, obviously this had an effect on what followed and the conclusions people drew as a result.
I'll stick a pin in this for now. I'm remembering a speech by an actor playing a squaddie in a WW II movie, where he talks about, why they are fighting, & when it's over how they'll have to clear away the rubble, & the slums, & provide jobs for the idle, & homes & spaces fit for the people.
At the time it was a brilliant piece of propaganda, but it spoke to the need, & the opportunity the end of the war would provide.
It wasn't just those who'd fought around the world; it was the women who'd been mobilized for the first time to the workforce, & those in the likes of the mines, who were treated like shit, with the Pit owners coining it during wartime, while the miners were having to work extra hours, for feck all money, & denied the right to strike. There were similar situations in other vital occupations like the shipyards where the workers in Glasgow, who were living in squalor, getting no extra money, getting bombed out of their homes, & the yard owners were in clover.
The;
"We're all in it together", line was never more obviously a lie, than during WW II, & by the end of the war, there was a movement for change, & that was why the NHS was a winning proposition, but it needed to be the first step.
In the US the GI Bill enabled a generation to attend College, who would never have had that opportunity, & the US has reaped the rewards for that since.