I like neeps wrote: Tue Feb 13, 2024 9:34 pm
I'm disappointed in Starmer because he has no plan for the UK, he has no policy, doesn't have any convictions.
It is true he's not a Tory crook or completely mental. But disappointed the platform he campaigner on to become leader has been completely disregarded which I'd have been excited about.
But his offer now is he's not a Tory (good) but can't do anything because the Tories have left no money (no good and not true).
If Labour aren't building the biggest coalition of voters possible, which means the people you disagree with too, then they're not going to get very far. It's not ideal but that's is the logic of FPTP. The Tories have given up the middle ground, they've given up trying to win.
I never used to vote Labour because I'm not a socialist, I was a lazy Lib Dem voter (lazy because UK liberals are rubbish compared to SA liberals, and the Lib Dems are usually a disappointment). None of it seemed to matter either. Then the Lib Dems helped out with austerity, which turned out to be the "good" Tory years. Then the Tories turned the UK immigration system into a dysfunctional chaotic mess, something which has had a personal negative impact. Then Brexit. I now vote every election against the Tories, which means voting Labour a lot. Tactical anti-Tory voting is the main thing the Tories fear this election, FPTP means voters have most impact when they vote against what they hate most rather than when they vote for something.
Starmer's leadership style looks like collective decision making. Not convinced he's dictating, it looks more like someone taking the middle ground from the views around him. When they're all agreed you get a strong outcome, when they're not it's fudge. A lot of the fudge looks like competent shadow cabinet members trying to fit what the party wants into something that gives the best chance of being elected which can also be delivered on afterwards. Maybe Starmer adopts a presidential style as PM and takes helicopter rides everywhere, but he's not there yet.