Random1 wrote: Sat Nov 07, 2020 7:16 pm
Yeah, that’s where I do disagree.
There are plenty of problems where these demographics do have a justifiable point. An example would be immigration.
For me, problems with immigration are substantially outweighed by the positives, especially over the long term.
But for people who live day by day, they don’t give a fuck about long term, nuanced benefits. They just see a simple and immediate supply and demand issue, that Brexit (Uk) and trump (US) promise to resolve.
They have a point.
Calling them morons is just an ad hominem approach that won’t work in my view.
I agree with you mate. I don’t think it is really all that helpful to label them as “stupid”. Your observation relating to “short term thinking” I think is spot-on to some extent.
But I think the biggest problem is te desire to ascribe to “simple solutions to complex problems”. There is no willingness to engage is nuance and the inter-relatedness of problems...every issue/problem has a simple solution.
Immigration? Just build a wall.
Islamist threats? Ban Muslims
Teen pregnancies leading to abortions? Close clinics
Hurricanes? Pray harder and blame the gays
Forest fires? Sweep up the kindling
Being smashed by China in trade? Put a tax on imports
Kids getting shot at school? More security and give teachers guns too!
Etc etc
While I loathe to call them stupid, there seems to be a large overlap between people looking for “simple answers” to life’s problems and religious folks as well. The simplest answer of “God did it” or “It was God’s will” has given a lot of them a lifetime of not questioning much in terms of cause and effect. This lack of skepticism also makes them ideal targets for grifters and conmen.
It’s a broad generalization though, and obviously can’t be applied to the whole group, but I think to a significant slice in both the USA and SA.